- Journal of an ignorant filmmaker
- Posts
- N.2 | "The Piano" (thinking of the piano scene), experience in movies vs. movie experience plus more
N.2 | "The Piano" (thinking of the piano scene), experience in movies vs. movie experience plus more
Also: tips on location scouting, the master shot and an update on my short (micro) film.
JOURNAL ENTRY
Aug 24, 2014: Tomorrow, Sunday, I’ll meet with my friend Alexy to do some tests for my upcoming short (micro) film. I want to test as much as possible. I want to test my camera (Sony a7 IV) with a Samyang 35mm f/2.8, the lighting and sound. We have some tungsten lights and a pro sound recorder (all Alexy’s stuff). The film is inspired by a scene of Leon: The Professional.
I want to do a good job this time. My last (and first) film was a disaster. I was sloppy as the director, the sound, lighting and footage were totally off. Everything was horrible. So much so that I’m not even making that public on YouTube. It’s set to unlisted.
But hey, in Rebel Without a Crew, Robert Rodriguez says that “…everyone has at least a dozen or so bad movies in them…”. So even if this one is another shitty one, it’s ok.
FILM STORYTELLING
The Piano (thinking of the piano scene)
The Piano
I watched The Piano again this week. I lost count of how many times I watched this work of art. I’ve loved this film since I was a teenager.
The director, Jane Campion, is a great inspiration. The cinematography by Stuart Dryburgh is simply beautiful. The score by Michael Nyman adds to the masterpiece’s beauty.
There’s this scene shot with a crane that’s really interesting. We start from above, where the shot looks as beautiful like a painting. From there we slowly go down to a closeup of Ada’s face. She’s sad thinking of the piano left on the beach.
TIDBIT I’M PONDERING
In the book Rebel Without a Crew, Robert Rodriguez says something interesting. I’m not sure I agree with him 100% but I like to contemplate contrarian takes that make me think. He says:
The most important and useful thing you need to be a filmmaker is “experience in movies,” as opposed to “movie experience.” They always tell you in film school […] [that] by working on other films, even as a production assistant, you get to see firsthand how others make movies.
Now, that’s exactly the kind of experience you don’t need.
You don’t want to learn how other people make movies, especially real Hollywood movies, because nine times out of ten their methods are wasteful and inefficient. […]
“Experience in movies,” […] is where you yourself get a borrowed camera […] and record images then manipulate those images in some kind of editing atmosphere […]. The idea is to experience creating your own images and/or stories no matter how crude they are and then manipulating them through editing.
Source: From Rebel Without a Crew by Robert Rodriguez.
PODCAST HIGHLIGHTS
Team Deakins: Episode 3: Location Scouting
Show up early
The earlier scouts are important because you want time with the director and the production designer talking about how the scene is going to work in the space you’re looking at in relation to the script.
There’s nothing like standing in a room, discussing it and talking about the blocking, the mood of the space (for the production designer) and more. Even if the location(s) doesn’t work at all for the film it’s key to be there and be discussing it.
It’s the cinematographer’s job
Location scouting is a key part of the creative process of the cinematographer. The idea of showing up to a location that’s been chosen by others and you’ve never seen before is not ideal. It can work, but it’s not ideal.
You should be prepared to get creative with the director and other people because it could change the vision of the film. It’s also important to be flexible and open and be prepared to have new ideas when looking at the location.
Be pragmatic
You have to be practical early on with things like location accessibility, natural and artificial lighting sources etc. The scout should also help you make an idea of the money involved with renting the location. All productions have a limited budget by nature and you need to let the producers know the cost involved.
Talk, talk, talk
Roger Deakins mentions he used to carry the viewfinder to scouts in the past, but now uses the app on his phone. Everybody can use the viewfinder app today, and this makes the location scout more open to discussions early on and fewer surprises down the line.
It’s ok to dream
It’s ok to imagine the sets as you want them to be while you storyboard. Then, you should go out there and see if you can find something to give you ideas and hone in slowly to create the look of the film.
It’s a jigsaw puzzle
When you’re choosing your location, you also want to think about the following: location cost, location place, actors’ and location’s availability. If all these pieces don’t fit together, you might as well build a set in a studio.
Weather and hotels
In case you have exteriors, you should think about cover sets (weather covers) in case of bad weather on your exteriors. This is an aspect that gets overlooked sometimes.
Don’t choose the “perfect” location without enough hotels for the entire crew.
Scouting’s crucial for small films
Location scouting is even more crucial for small productions. Small film productions don’t have enough money to throw at problems. You have to make sure the location you choose will work.
Source: From Episode 3: LOCATION SCOUTING of The Team Deakins podcast.
FILM STORYTELLING
The master shot
The Godfather Part II
The master shot (or "master") confirms the location and geography of the scene.
It also frames what characters are in the scene and where they are in relation to each other.
The master captures the scene playing out in its entirety.